Grammar and spell checker: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Hugo Voisard
No edit summary
imported>Hugo Voisard
Line 8: Line 8:
==Grammar Checker==
==Grammar Checker==
[[Image:Screenshot_ooo.png|right|thumb|250px|[http://www.languagetool.org/ LanguageTool], [[GUI]] when used within [[OpenOffice.org]]]].
[[Image:Screenshot_ooo.png|right|thumb|250px|[http://www.languagetool.org/ LanguageTool], [[GUI]] when used within [[OpenOffice.org]]]].
 
Creating a grammar checker is much more complex than creating a spell checker. Not only does it require a word list like a spell checker does, but it also requires those words to be tagged properly and a set of grammar rules to describe the way words should be placed in a sentence.
Creating a grammar checker is much more complex than creating a spell checker. Not only does it require a word list like a spell checker does, but it also requires those words to be tagged properly and a set of grammar rules to describe the way words should be placed in a sentence.  


==Checker Issues==
==Checker Issues==

Revision as of 01:37, 28 November 2007

A checker is a type of software that emable automatic detection of misspelled words, and sometimes ungrammatical phrases too.

Spell Checker

When right-clicking on an underlined word within Firefox, you can see a list of similar words to replace it.

Spell checking can be considered as the basis for checking softwares. Spell checking capabilities can be found among other things as an add-on for Firefox (browser), as an add-on for (Pidgin) (instant messaging client) or within an email service such as Gmail. Spell checking usually comes with a closest word suggestion feature. A spell checker alone does not detect anything wrong with correctly spelled words placed next to one another when they don't make sense, as long as they are spelled correctly.

Grammar Checker

LanguageTool, GUI when used within OpenOffice.org

.

Creating a grammar checker is much more complex than creating a spell checker. Not only does it require a word list like a spell checker does, but it also requires those words to be tagged properly and a set of grammar rules to describe the way words should be placed in a sentence.

Checker Issues

Noise

A common issue with spell and grammar checkers is noise. For instance, some French grammar checkers report "Nous nous" as a mistake. However, this phrase is common in French ("Nous nous sommes lavés": "We washed ourselves"). This alert is triggered as a noise for the doublet-detecting rule.

Irrelevant alerts are also triggered when a spell checker does not recognize a word. This is most like to happen with surnames, neologisms, archaisms, and rare words.

Silence

Silence is another common issue with spell checking. This is caused by the extent of rules to be created to list all possible mistakes. Agreement rules are usually the first to be covered with grammar checking. However, grammar mistakes are just one of part of mistakes that can be made. Use of substandard English is also possible in other ways and can concern regionalisms, dated phrases, offensive phrases, slang, etc.

External Links

  • LanguageTool, an open source grammar checker with mature support for English and limited support for other languages that can be used as a stand-alone application
  • SpellCheck Plus, an online proprietary grammar checker (although the name does not suggest it) which can be tried for free, but with limitations